| Year | Show |
| 2019 | Rumpelstiltskin |
| You’re Only Young Twice |
| 2018 | Robin Hood |
| Sleighed To Death |
| 2017 | Dick Whittington |
| It Runs In The Family |
| 2016 | Aladdin and the Pirates |
| Love and Money |
| 2015 | Rapunzel |
| Don’t get your Vicars in a Twist |
| 2014 | Puss In Boots |
| Ghosts at the Grange |
| 2013 | Cinderella |
| Find the Lady |
| 2012 | Jack and the Beanstalk |
| Tiptoe through the Tombstones |
| 2011 | Goldilocks and the Three Bears |
| Cash on Delivery |
| 2010 | Sleeping Beauty |
| Holiday Snap |
| 2009 | Mother Goose |
| Love begins at Fifty |
| 2008 | Dick Whittington |
| Write about what you know |
| 2007 | Babes in the Wood |
| Death by Fatal Murder |
| 2006 | Pirates in Petticoats |
| Secondary Cause of Death |
| 2005 | Red Riding Hood |
| Hidden Meaning |
| 2004 | Aladdin |
| Now that’s what I call musicals |
| 2003 | Beauty and the Beast |
| Murdered to Death |
| 2002 | Cinderella |
| Back to the Sixties |
| 2001 | Rapunzel |
| Key for two |
| 2000 | Pinnochio |
| Wartime Memories |
| 1999 | Ali Baba |
| Confusions |
| 1998 | Humpty Dumpty |
| Old Thyme Music Hall |
| 1997 | Jack and the Beanstalk |
| Snappy Families |
| 1996 | Babes in the Wood |
| Sea Breeze |
| 1995 | Puss in Boots |
| There goes the bride |
| 1994 | Robinson Crusoe |
| Wild Goose Chase |
| 1993 | Hickory Dickory Dock (Dec) |
| Darling Mr London |
| 1992 | The Grande Old Duke of York (Jan 93) |
| Tomb with a view |
| 1991 | Aladdin |
| Dark and Stormy Night |
| 1990 | Mother Goose |
| Move Over Mrs Markham |
| 1989 | Sleeping Beauty |
| A basin full of briny |
| 1988 | Dick Whittington |
| A colourful evening |
| 1987 | Jack and the beanstalk |
| Live at the Church House |
| 1986 | Confusions |
| Easter extravaganza |
| 1985 | A Victorian evening |
| Little boxes |
| 1984 | March Madness |
| Larkrise to Candleford |
| 1983 | Caucasian chalk circle |
| The Dragon |
| 1982 | Ernies incredible illucinations |
